The Liability of Green Fund Managers: An In-Depth Analysis.

What are green funds and why are they so important?

In a world increasingly aware of environmental and social challenges, green funds have emerged as an attractive investment tool. These financial vehicles promise to generate returns while investing in companies and projects that promote sustainability and positive impact.

Sustainability and positive impact are fundamental pillars of responsible investment. When we talk about green funds, we are referring to investment vehicles that seek to generate a financial return while contributing to a more sustainable future. These funds carefully select the companies and projects in which they invest, prioritising those that demonstrate a genuine commitment to the environment and society.

Sustainability in a green fund involves responsible management of natural resources, reduction of carbon footprint and promotion of ethical business practices. Fund managers rigorously assess the environmental, social and corporate governance performance of companies, known as ESG criteria.

Positive impact refers to the concrete and measurable benefits that green funds generate beyond financial returns. These benefits can range from reducing greenhouse gas emissions to creating jobs in disadvantaged communities.

Similarly, various tools and methodologies, such as ESG indicators and international benchmarks, are used to measure the positive impact of a green fund.

What are ESG objectives?

ESG stands for Environmental, Social and Governance. These objectives are not mere statements of good intentions, but represent tangible commitments that companies make to their stakeholders, i.e. all parties interested in their business, from investors and employees to customers and local communities.

By setting ESG targets, companies are demonstrating greater transparency in their operations and greater responsibility towards society and the environment. These targets allow companies to assess their performance more accurately and objectively, identify areas for improvement and make strategic decisions aligned with their sustainability commitments.

ESG objectives cover a wide range of issues, from reducing carbon footprint and water consumption to promoting diversity and inclusion in the workplace and strengthening relationships with local communities. Each company sets its own ESG objectives depending on its size, sector of activity and operating context. However, there are some general principles that tend to guide this process, such as materiality, measurability and alignment with business strategy.

Materiality refers to the relative importance of an ESG issue for a particular company. ESG objectives should focus on those aspects that have a significant impact on the business and its stakeholders. Measurability implies that objectives should be quantifiable and verifiable, so that progress towards their achievement can be assessed. Finally, alignment with business strategy means that ESG objectives should be integrated into the company’s strategic planning and contribute to long-term value creation.

Si te ha interesado este artículo no dudes en leer:

Green or False? Business Sustainability Under the Microscope: Unraveling the New Rules and Requirements

Business sustainability has ceased to be an option and has become an obligation. The recent European CSRD directive and its transposition in Spain are revolutionizing the landscape, imposing new and more demanding information requirements on companies.

Due Diligence in Sustainable Investment

Green fund managers have a legal and ethical obligation to conduct thorough due diligence before investing in any asset. This due diligence should include a rigorous assessment of the ESG criteria of potential companies and projects. If a manager fails to comply with this obligation and makes investments that are not aligned with the stated ESG objectives, he or she may be held civilly liable.

The Protection of Minority Investors

Minority investors, who are often attracted to green funds because of their values and beliefs, are particularly vulnerable to malpractice. If a green fund fails to meet its ESG objectives, these investors may suffer financial losses and reputational damage. Legislation in many countries provides specific protections for minority investors, which can lead to legal action against fund managers who fail to meet their obligations.

Civil Liability in the Event of Non-Compliance

Green fund managers may be held civilly liable in case of non-compliance with ESG objectives for a number of reasons, including:

• False advertising: If a fund manager promotes a fund as “green” or “sustainable” when it is not, he or she can be accused of false advertising.
• Breach of contract: Investors in green funds have a contract with the manager, which often includes specific ESG commitments. If the manager fails to meet these commitments, it can be held liable for breach of contract.
• Negligence: If a manager fails to perform adequate due diligence or fails to adequately monitor investments, it may be considered negligent.

The consequences of non-compliance with ESG objectives can be severe for fund managers. In addition to civil liability, managers may face regulatory sanctions, reputational damage and loss of investor confidence.

The Importance of Specialised Legal Advice

The complexity of green fund regulation and the growing importance of sustainability make specialist legal advice essential. A law firm with expertise in corporate law and green fund matters can provide invaluable guidance to managers.

This advice ranges from drafting clear and concise investment documents, which precisely define the ESG objectives and the manager’s obligations, to conducting thorough due diligence to ensure that investments are aligned with these objectives. In addition, a specialised law firm can handle any legal disputes that may arise in relation to non-compliance with ESG objectives. In short, specialist legal advice is essential to successfully navigating the complex landscape of sustainable investing.

Conclusion

Liability of green fund managers is an increasingly relevant issue in today’s financial landscape. Investors expect green funds to deliver on their sustainability promises, and regulators are increasingly imposing requirements to ensure that they do. Fund managers who fail to meet their obligations can face serious consequences.

If you liked this article, you may also find it interesting to read the following one:

Why ESG Should Be the Heart of Your M&A Strategy: Unlock Synergies and Growth Potential